SC agrees to hear plea challenging Centre’s decision to ban BBC documentary
First Published: 30th January, 2023 19:17 IST
A separate petition filed by senior journalist N Ram and advocate Prashant Bhushan on taking down tweets with links to the BBC documentary will also be heard on Monday
The Supreme Court on Monday agreed to hear on February 6 a PIL challenging the Centre’s decision to ban the controversial BBC documentary on Prime Minister Narendra Modi and the 2002 Gujarat riots.
Advocate ML Sharma has filed the petition calling the ban on ‘India: The Modi Question’ malafide, arbitrary and unconstitutional.
A separate petition filed by senior journalist N Ram and advocate Prashant Bhushan on taking down tweets with links to the BBC documentary will also be heard on Monday.
A bench comprising Chief Justice of India (CJI) DY Chandrachud and justices P S Narasimha and JB Pardiwala took note of the submissions of ML Sharma and senior advocate CU Singh seeking urgent listing of their separate PILs on the issue.
The Centre recently directed social media platforms Twitter and YouTube to block links to the documentary. The ministry of external affairs has trashed the documentary as a “propaganda piece” that lacks objectivity and reflects a colonial mindset. The documentary questions Narendra Modi’s handling of the riots who was the chief minister of Gujarat then.
At the outset of the proceedings, lawyer Sharma, who has filed a PIL in his personal capacity, mentioned the plea, saying that people were being arrested.
“It will be listed on Monday,” the CJI said.
Senior advocate CU Singh mentioned a separate plea on the issue filed by Ram and Bhushan. He mentioned how the tweets by Ram and Bhushan were deleted allegedly by using emergency powers. He also said that students in Ajmer were rusticated for streaming the BBC documentary. “We will list,” the CJI said.
The PIL also urged the apex court to call and examine the BBC documentary – both parts I and II – and sought action against persons who were responsible and involved directly and indirectly with the 2002 Gujarat riots.
“That cause of arose to file present petition arose to the petitioner on 21st January 2023 when respondent invoking rule 16 of IT rule 2021 prohibited citizen of India to see BBC documentary consisting/ disclosing true facts of Gujrat riot 2002 butchering of citizen of India in 2002 without adopting constitutional provisions which is a serious injury to the constitutional systems of the India and cannot be repaired if not quashed,” the plea said.
The ban amounts to a violation of freedom of speech and expression under Article 19(1)(a), it was contended.
The plea also sought a probe into those responsible for the Gujarat riots.
(This copy was first published by Hindustan Times)
Also read: ‘Witch hunt against PM Modi’: Indian diaspora in London protests outside BBC headquarters
COMMENTS

TOPMOST STORY NOW

Live Tensions Soar in Tripura Over Kokborok Script Row, Students Threaten Statewide Agitation
18th March 2025
Live Missing Manipur Youth’s Mother Appeals for His Safe Return, Meets Top Officials
18th March 2025
Live Excitement Soars in Shillong as India Gears Up for Historic Football Clash Against Maldives Tomorrow
18th March 2025
Live Karnataka School Shut, Owner and Hostel Warden Arrested After 2 Meghalaya Students Die
18th March 2025WE RECOMMEND

Dog’s Head Found in a Momo Factory. How Safe is Your Favourite Momo?
The momo factory had been supplying nearly a quintal of momos and spring rolls daily to Chandigarh, Panchkula, and Kalka for the past two years
18th March 2025
“Holi is a Crime for Muslims”: Cleric Razvi Targets Cricketer Mohammed Shami Again For His Daughter Playing Holi
Cleric Razvi Targets Mohammed Shami: Razvi stated that he had previously advised Shami to adhere to Islamic teachings.
17th March 2025
NSA Ajit Doval, US Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard discuss India-US ties
As per the official website of Raisina Dialogue, Gabbard will participate in a keynote conversation with Samir Saran, President, ORF.
17th March 2025
PM Modi’s Podcast with Lex Fridman Drops Today. All You Need to Know About Lex
The podcast will cover a wide range of topics, including PM Modi’s childhood memories, his years in the Himalayas, and his journey in public life.
16th March 2025
Assam CM Himanta Biswa Sarma Lashes Out At Congress Leader Jairam Ramesh
While Jairam Ramesh condemned the arrest as an "abuse of police powers," CM Sarma defended the arrest
16th March 2025